Does Affirmative Action Hurt Historically Black Colleges and Universities?

Monday, May 12, 2003

 - Sean Turner

Morris Brown College, in Atlanta, Georgia, having recently lost its accreditation, has suspended its sports programs and laid off its coaches. Unfortunately, Morris Brown is not alone in this growing list of historically black colleges and universities, or HBCU’s, facing extinction due to financial or academic woes. Grambling State University in Louisiana, known for its legendary football coach Eddie Robinson, faces a similar threat due to accounting discrepancies.

Recently, as many as six HBCU’s have been given warnings or placed on probation by accreditation agencies, and many others are struggling with budget shortfalls, ill-prepared students, and inadequate facilities. Financial mismanagement notwithstanding, what other significant factor has contributed to the bleak future of HBCU’s? The answer lies at the feet of an initiative whose intent was to redress past racial and sexual discrimination: Affirmative Action.

The history of HBCU’s predates the Civil War. The earliest HBCU, Cheyney University in Pennsylvania, was formed in 1837 by Richard Humphreys; a Quaker philanthropist from Philadelphia, who started the then-named “Institute for Colored Youth” to counter the prevailing practice of limiting or prohibiting the education of blacks. Despite the effects of the economic depression, between 1929 and 1940, enrollment at HBCU’s rose by 66 percent compared to a rise of 36 percent at all colleges. By 1940, 85 percent of blacks that attended college went to traditionally black colleges.

Desegregation provided the opportunity for blacks to attend traditionally white schools, while drawing some of the brightest black students and professors away from traditionally black colleges in the process. In 1965, an executive order was issued by President Lyndon Johnson requiring government contractors to "take affirmative action" toward prospective minority employees in all aspects of hiring and employment. This order was later amended in 1967 to cover discrimination on the basis of gender.

Increasingly, many HBCU’s have had trouble competing for students, faculty, and money at a time when they're facing greater competition for black students and teachers. Major public and private schools began aggressively recruiting black applicants to meet racial quotas precipitated by affirmative action. By 1971, only 34 percent of black students were enrolling in HBCU’s, and in 2000, that figure dropped to just 18 percent. Declining enrollments led some schools to market themselves to a broader demographic, with low tuitions attracting an increasing number of white students.

Today, there are roughly 105 HBCU’s. However, over the past 26 years, 12 HBCU’s have closed primarily due to money problems resulting from declining enrollments and endowments. Contributing to this phenomenon is the continual push for racial quotas in predominately white colleges in the guise of so-called “diversity initiatives”. As government officials, civil rights leaders, et al, remain steadfast in their support of such discriminatory practices, a significant number of black students continually fail or drop out of colleges in which they are unprepared to compete academically.

These are among the many unintended consequences of affirmative action or quotas. Many supporters of both the existence of HBCU’s and affirmative action either ignore or fail to realize the cancerous relationship between the two. As the admissions standards of predominately white colleges are continually lowered to satisfy the “diversity” façade, so too is the viability of HBCU’s, save a few. Will these same supporters acknowledge this trend, and decide which is more precious: the prestigious history and success of HBCU’s for blacks, or failed government policies? Perhaps, but only after more HBCU’s follow in the footsteps of Morris Brown, and legacies of academic achievement among blacks in America have been lost to the history books.